Cognitive empathy and IQ are directly proportional and if you take an empathy test, you may confirm that IQ and emotional empathy are correlated and are inversely proportional to one another, which means, if you have a high IQ or you are high on cognitive empathy, you will have a low emotional empathy towards other people and vice versa.
However, there is no conclusive evidence against the claim as yet, but a speech by Daniel Goleman at TED TALKS – “Why aren’t we more compassionate?” claimed that there is zero correlation between IQ and emotional empathy; they are controlled by different parts of the brain.
Although there is no complete evidence about correlation between IQ and emotional empathy, this study however could slightly clear the complication.
So, how does the brains of emotional people respond towards other’s feelings differ as compared to the ones who respond more rationally? Researchers at Monash University have the answer and they have found physical differences in the brains of emotional people and rational people.
The researchers studied the correlation between grey matter density and cognitive and affective empathy and examined whether people who have more brain cells in certain areas of the brain are better at responding to different types of empathy.
Robert Eres, who is the lead researcher of the study said that people who have high emotional empathy are often those who get quite fearful when watching a horror movie, or those who cry during a sad scene, and those who are high on cognitive empathy are more rational. These are the kind of people who simply know someone else’s
feeling, what they might be thinking and those who can help in a negotiation or in motivating people. For example, a psychologist counselling a client.
The researchers studied 176 participants and used voxel-based morphometry (VBM) on them to examine the extent of grey matter density. Based on what they scored, the researchers rated their levels for cognitive empathy compared to affective or emotional empathy. They found that participants with high scores for affective empathy had greater grey matter density in the insula – a region of the brain deep in the cerebral cortex. And those who scored higher for cognitive empathy had greater density in the midcingulate cortex – a region above the corpus callosum, which connects the two hemispheres of the brain.
The study published in the journal NeuroImage, confirms that empathy is a multi-component construct and the individual differences in empathy are subserved by anatomical differences. It also raises questions such as – if some kinds of empathy could be increased through training or if people can lose their capacity for empathy of they don’t use it enough.
“Every day people use empathy with, and without, their knowledge to navigate the social world,” said Mr Eres.
“We use it for communication, to build relationships, and consolidate our understanding of others.”
The study also raises further questions like whether people could train themselves to be more empathic, and would those areas of the brain become larger if they did, or whether we can lose our ability to empathise if we don’t use it enough.
“In the future we want to investigate causation by testing whether training people on empathy related tasks can lead to changes in these brain structures and investigate if damage to these brain structures, as a result of a stroke for example, can lead to empathy impairments,” said Mr Eres. [Hat Tip: Monash University; Image via melissamcphail.com]
There’s been a lot written about EQ vs. IQ since the late 80’s. I’ve always felt the mark of highest inteligence was a strong mix of both.
Yeah. But one claim will criticise the other and it will go on forever. 🙂
Well, ‘monkey see, monkey do’. If people watch television shows about murder and mahem and the unemotional responses to it by the actors, or comedy shows that use personal ridicule and slap-stick humor, I pretty sure, you’re going to be less compassionate.
When I stopped watching TV for several years, then would see a show, I had the same response you described, I would feel fear while watching a horror scence, or cry at a sad scene. It’s as though, the hiatus from television allowed my empathy to develope naturally, again. That so much early TV had desensitized me emotionally.
I have a very high IQ and am very empathetic, and I see no correlation between the two in my life. My IQ has increased with experience, as has my empathy. The saying, ‘what doesn’t kill you only makes you stronger’, should also include, ‘and more sympathetic to others’. That’s what I’ve found.
Stop watching shows that make you emotionally unresponsive. I think it’s media brain-washing, not individual traits. There’s nothing in the world that can make me believe that media influence is not real and mostly negative to how we relate to others. Cheers, B. J. Hollywood
Well, I took an empathy test and the resulted in very low empathy score. So, I guess it’s different for everyone and for me IQ and empathy are inversely proportional. Watching any kinds of shows, horror, romantic or emotional, doesn’t affect my emotion really. 🙂
Hey, take a test of a different kind. Stop watching TV, for a few months, and let me know what happens, if anything. Think you could do it? Cheers, B. J.
Nothing is impossible. Cheers! 🙂
Just some things aren’t very likely, eh. Well, not many people would give up their TV time for an experiment. You should check out my post, “It’s not ‘the Man’, it’s the mix…” on ttgtloa.wordpress.com. I’d be curious to hear what you think of it. Cheers, B. J.
They have omitted environmental factors like religion, ethics and morals. The brain does not operate merely on IQ or emotional DNA programming.
Agree. Environmental factors like religions, ethics and morals do have an influence on IQ.